NTSC, PAL and SMPTE

NTSC, PAL, and SECAM—once the backbone of global analog television—are now relics of a bygone era, abandoned in favor of digital broadcasting standards like ATSC, DVB, and SMPTE-compliant formats. But back when the world still ran on cathode-ray tubes, these regional standards dictated how moving images reached people’s screens. NTSC, born in the U.S. in 1940 under the FCC’s watch, first standardized black-and-white broadcasts before rolling out a notoriously unstable color system in 1953. PAL, developed in the 1960s by German engineer Walter Bruch, fixed NTSC’s color inconsistencies by introducing phase alternation (hence the name) and quickly became Europe and Asia’s preferred choice. Meanwhile, France, ever the rebel, came up with SECAM—"Sequential Color with Memory"—a system that worked well for its intended regions (France, Russia, and parts of Africa) but wasn’t exactly built for easy compatibility. None of these were truly global standards; instead, they were maintained by regional regulatory bodies like the FCC (for NTSC) and the European Broadcasting Union (for PAL), ensuring that a TV sold in one country actually worked there. Fast-forward to today, and analog signals are dead, buried under the digital wave. Now, the world runs on SMPTE, ITU-R, and various digital video broadcasting systems, making NTSC, PAL, and SECAM nothing more than historical footnotes—curiosities of an era when “video format” wasn’t just a setting on a smartphone.

While standardization did ensure compatibility within specific regions, the primary reason different TV broadcast standards (NTSC, PAL, SECAM) were developed was due to technical and political factors rather than intentional signal blocking.

• Technical Reasons: Different regions had varying electrical power frequencies (e.g., 60Hz in the U.S. vs. 50Hz in Europe), which influenced the refresh rates of television systems. Additionally, different bandwidth allocations and color encoding methods were chosen based on available technology and regional needs.

• Political and Economic Factors: Some countries adopted unique standards (like SECAM in France and the Soviet Union) partly to control media influence from foreign broadcasts, but this wasn't the main driving force behind standardization.

old TV

You might still come across references to them while navigating your editing software’s sequence settings. And in case you’re wondering what they were, here’s a detailed breakdown.

NTSC vs. PAL vs. SMPTE – A Detailed Breakdown

1. NTSC (National Television System Committee)

NTSC was the analog television standard primarily used in North America, parts of South America, and some Asian countries. It was developed in 1953 as a standard for broadcast television.

Key Features of NTSC:

• Frame Rate: 29.97 fps (interlaced), originally 30 fps before the introduction of color broadcasting.

• Resolution: Standard-definition (SD) resolution of 720×480 pixels (480i).

• Color Encoding: Uses a YIQ color system. The color signals are encoded separately from the luminance, which caused problems like color shifting due to signal degradation.

• Interlacing: Uses 2:1 interlaced scanning (odd and even fields displayed alternately).

• Refresh Rate: 59.94 Hz, tied to the U.S. electrical system (60 Hz).

• Black Level: 7.5 IRE, making blacks appear slightly elevated compared to other standards.

• Compatibility Issues: NTSC struggled with color stability, leading to the phrase "Never The Same Color" due to hue shifts.

Where NTSC Was Used:

• United States, Canada, Japan, Mexico, South Korea, Taiwan, and parts of Latin America (e.g., Colombia, Chile).

2. PAL (Phase Alternating Line)

PAL was developed in the 1960s as an improvement over NTSC, primarily used in Europe, Australia, and parts of Asia and Africa. It aimed to fix NTSC’s color stability issues by using a phase-alternating method.

Key Features of PAL:

• Frame Rate: 25 fps (interlaced).

• Resolution: Standard-definition (SD) resolution of 720×576 pixels (576i).

• Color Encoding: Uses a YUV system with phase alternation, which averages out hue errors, resulting in better color accuracy.

• Interlacing: Uses 2:1 interlaced scanning.

• Refresh Rate: 50 Hz (tied to European electrical systems).

• Black Level: 0 IRE (true black).

• Better Color Stability: Unlike NTSC, PAL does not suffer from color drift because it inverts the phase of the color signal every frame, canceling out errors.

• Slight Speed-Up Effect: Since film is traditionally shot at 24 fps, converting to PAL (25 fps) causes a 4% speed-up, making movies slightly shorter and pitch slightly higher in audio.

Where PAL Was Used:

• Europe, Australia, India, China, most of Africa, and some parts of Asia and South America.

3. SECAM (Séquentiel Couleur à Mémoire)

Though not as widely discussed as NTSC and PAL, SECAM was used in France, Russia, and some parts of Africa. It used a different approach to color transmission, making it incompatible with both NTSC and PAL.

Key Features of SECAM:

• Frame Rate: 25 fps (interlaced).

• Resolution: 720×576 pixels (576i).

• Color Encoding: Uses FM-modulated color encoding rather than phase-based like NTSC/PAL.

• Refresh Rate: 50 Hz.

• Better Color Stability: Unlike NTSC, SECAM was less susceptible to signal degradation. However, it was harder to edit due to its color modulation method.

Where SECAM Was Used:

• France, Russia, former Soviet territories, and some parts of Africa.

4. SMPTE (Society of Motion Picture and Television Engineers)

SMPTE refers to a set of modern digital video standards used in professional film, broadcast, and digital cinema. Unlike NTSC and PAL, which were analog, SMPTE defines digital video standards, frame rates, and color spaces for modern workflows.

Key Features of SMPTE Video Standards:

• Digital, Not Analog: Replaces PAL/NTSC for HD, UHD, and cinema.

• Frame Rates:

  • 24 fps (standard for film and digital cinema).

  • 25 fps (European broadcast, replacing PAL).

  • 29.97 fps (legacy compatibility with NTSC-based workflows).

  • 30 fps, 48 fps, 60 fps, 120 fps (used in modern digital formats).

• Resolutions:

  • HD (1920×1080, 1280×720)

  • UHD (3840×2160, 7680×4320 – 8K)

  • Digital Cinema (2K: 2048×1080, 4K: 4096×2160, etc.)

• Color Spaces:

  • Rec. 709 (HDTV standard).

  • Rec. 2020 (UHD and HDR standard).

  • DCI-P3 (digital cinema standard).

  • XYZ Color Space (used in Digital Cinema Packages).

• Interlaced vs. Progressive:

  • SMPTE standards favor progressive scanning over interlaced video (used in NTSC/PAL), which results in higher quality.

Why SMPTE Matters Now:

• Defines professional video standards for broadcast, streaming, and digital cinema.

• Enables interoperability between different regions and formats.

• Supports high dynamic range (HDR), wide color gamut (WCG), and high frame rates (HFR).

Comparison Table: NTSC vs. PAL vs. SMPTE

Feature	NTSC	PAL	SMPTE
Frame Rate	29.97 fps	25 fps	24, 25, 30, 48, 60, 120 fps
Resolution	720×480 (480i)	720×576 (576i)	HD, UHD, 2K, 4K, 8K
Color Encoding	YIQ	YUV (phase alternation)	Rec. 709, Rec. 2020, DCI-P3, XYZ
Black Level	7.5 IRE	0 IRE	True black (depends on color space)
Refresh Rate	59.94 Hz	50 Hz	Variable
Interlaced or Progressive	Interlaced	Interlaced	Progressive preferred
Compatibility Issues	Hue shifting	4% speed-up issue	No legacy analog issues
Regions Used	North America, Japan, Korea	Europe, Australia, India	Worldwide (modern standard)